<!-- copy: internal — QA verdict for 02-c4b, machine-written, not ad copy -->

# QA — 02-c4b (stage: chunk)

1 fatal, 3 major, 1 minor, 0 cosmetic (cosmetic = a viewer cannot see it at full speed)

| At | Kind | Severity | Notice | What |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0s | sound | fatal | 3 | far too quiet to be an ad: mean volume -23.0 dB, peak -5.1 dB. A voiced ad sits near -17 dB. If the donor carried music, no bed was laid under this cut. |
| 0.0s | wrong-product | major | 2 | Held deodorant product has incorrect distorted label text: the brand logo is not the correct 'doe' text from the reference product, and all lower label lines are misprinted/garbled and do not match the reference. Product is centre frame, clearly held. |
| 2.2s | speech | major | ? | brand said as "one" instead of "Doe" |
| 3.7s | wrong-product | major | 2 | The brand logo on the front of the deodorant changes entirely to a small star symbol, no longer matching any correct branding from the reference product. |
| 0.9s | hands | minor | 1 | Fingers on the hand holding the deodorant are distorted, merged unnaturally with wrong shapes while moving the bottle. |

## What the video says

for the summer because they're giving away a third one free when you get two.  So they're literally flying off the freaking shelves like crazy.

## The reviewer, in full

```
[
{"t": 0.0, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "at_a_cut": false, "what": "Held deodorant product has incorrect distorted label text: the brand logo is not the correct 'doe' text from the reference product, and all lower label lines are misprinted/garbled and do not match the reference. Product is centre frame, clearly held."},
{"t": 0.9, "kind": "hands", "notice": 1, "severity": "minor", "at_a_cut": false, "what": "Fingers on the hand holding the deodorant are distorted, merged unnaturally with wrong shapes while moving the bottle."},
{"t": 3.7, "kind": "wrong-product", "notice": 2, "severity": "major", "at_a_cut": false, "what": "The brand logo on the front of the deodorant changes entirely to a small star symbol, no longer matching any correct branding from the reference product."}
]
```